Forget all those perfect, pristine, magnificent, jealousy-inducing photos of sketchbooks and stop pressurising yourself by judging yourself against these, regarding these as what you ought to be achieving. The goal is to be sketching, drawing, paintings, visual-journalling. It doesn’t matter what you want to label it, nor does it matter what level of skill or success you do it with. What matters is that you’re doing it.
Anyone who claims every sketch they do is perfect is lying or self-censoring or doing only what they know works and not extending themselves, not continuing to learn. Photos of sketchbook pages are selective; you rarely see someone showing every single page in a sketchbook. After all, we like to appear competent.
Take the above photo of a sheep sketch for instance, snapped on location after I’d finished it (see “Sunny Summer Skye Sketching“). It was one of three I did of sheep on that spot, one after another; the other two were overworked duds. I resisted scratching through them in frustration and irritation; I certainly didn’t take photos!
Artist John Muir Laws compares warming up your drawing muscles to making “sacrificial pancakes“, the first few won’t be perfect and you know they won’t, but you also know you need to make them. One of his helpful tips in his blog “How to get started with Nature Journaling” is to move the goal post:
“Do not focus on trying to make pretty pictures … Open your journal with the intention of discovering something new … If you notice something that you otherwise would not have seen, remember it more vividly, or start asking yourself more interesting questions about what you observe than the journaling is a success. Embrace this idea and go. …Art is a side effect of the process of journaling.“
Sketching makes me look harder and longer. Serial sketching (multiple sketches of the same subject) helps me slow down, lets me try various ideas, and increases the odds I’ll end up with a “good sketch” rather than merely “recorded information”. You could call it hit-or-miss, but I prefer to call it visual exploration.
12 Replies to “Lower Your Expectations When Sketching”
This is a great post Marion. I don’t do a lot of sketching and more and more I realize that I should be doing so and the reason is I find that my sketches look terrible especially compared to a piece I’m focused on with all the detail. So this is a great reminder for me to not be so hard on myself and get my sketchbook out and take it with me and actually use it.
Thanks for sharing this,
Thanks Terry! I think the photos of fabulously finished sketches mislead us into thinking that’s what we should be doing, diverting from sketching being information gathering and observation. If you look at Monet’s sketches, you’ll see many that are only a few lines, the recording of an idea. There are some late sketches that if you didn’t know about his lily pond reflection paintings would seem like random scribbles.
I needed to read this! I foolishly allowed someone to look at one of my sketchbooks – he found a picture of a rowing-boat and remarked that the perspective was wrong: I KNOW it was wrong, I didn’t need telling – it didn’t matter, so long as in the picture I painted from it, I got it right. I’m often suspicious of pictures from people’s sketch-books which show almost perfect paintings in watercolour or excellent sketches: if you trawled though a dozen of mine, you’d find a few OK sketches and splashes of paint, but they’d be few and far between because that’s not what a sketch-book is for…. I think I shall leave instructions that my sketch-books should be burned on my death…..
I think we need a new name for those books full of finished paintings, something other than sketchbook 🙂
Sketching is just that, sketching. it is not meant to be finished artwork, but you taking notes. playing around some times, but it does not need to be perfect. That’s not the point. It sharpens your powers of observation. Helps you focus. or simply to relax. Sketch does so much for you that making it have to be perfect is just adding a real burden to the process. That is why so many people avoid it, because they think they have to be perfect and it has to be complete.
I have taken to sketch with a pen. So I can’t erase and have to simply go on.
Yes, pen is great because as you say it forces you to simply go on, or start anew. None of the endless changing of mind that we can do with a pencil and eraser.
I have found that my gestural sketching is much better than when I try to take my time and do it right. Working fast with quick looks at the paper is a much better way for me to get the figures down on paper for later reference.
I think the thought that it’s a gestural sketch liberates us, gives us permission to get it wrong, and perversely that’s why we get it right because the pressure’s off and we don’t overthink it but let our inherent knowledge lead.
Hello Marion, this has been really helpful tome. I was afraid to sketch anything just in case it was seen and I would be embarrassed. I will now sketch with impunity, what a wonderful feeling of release, thank you. Feel sure my art will now move forward. I really loved your article. The best advice I have ever read.
What’s in a sketchbook needs relevance for ourselves only, bits of observations, thoughts, ideas etc etc. Don’t feel compelled to let people see a sketchbook either, but if you do, don’t apologize for it, leave people to take from it what they will. You know why you do what you do in it!
I have my attempts at sketching the mill pond at Skyeworks. Every time I look at it the “real” mind picture flashes up. For clarification: I am Marion’s mother but I last did art work in primary school 70 years ago.
Narrowing the gap between what I sketch and what I see in our mind’s eye is the challenge I enjoy. What I envisage the drawing or painting to be may be realistic or it may be expressive, it depends on what I’m after, but that translation from mind to hand to drawing is infrequently seamless.