Monday Motivator: External Expectations

Monday Motivator

… the distinction between fiction and nonfiction is less about “Did it really happen or was it made up?” than it is about form. And, more than form, it’s about the expectations that are brought to certain forms. According to how a book is presented, packaged, or identified, readers have certain expectations. Following from that they expect books within broadly identified categories to behave in certain ways. So people can find it quite disconcerting when a book isn’t doing what they think it’s meant to be doing, even if the book is completely fine on its own terms and has no desire to conform to some external set of expectations.

Geoff Dyer, “The Art of Nonfiction No. 6“, interviewed by Matthew Specktor, Paris Review Issue 207, Winter 2013

Substitute “drawing” for “fiction”, “painting” for “nonfiction”, and “art” for “book”.

Saying a drawing or painting is ‘good’ because ‘it looks like a photograph’ is more a statement about the viewer than the artwork, about the limited exploration someone has had with the possibilities of art beyond representational.

It can be interesting debating whether pastel is a drawing or a painting medium, when ink shifts from a drawing to a painting, how much paint can be added to a mixed medium piece before it stops being a drawing, but ultimately it’s a technicality that’s irrelevant to whether an artwork speaks to you or not.

Mixed media, A2 size

Add a comment here: